Who Pays for Fence Between Neighbors in California

good neighbor fence

When it comes to property boundaries, fences are a common source of contention between neighbors. In California, determining who pays for a fence can sometimes be a complex issue, as the state has specific laws that govern this matter. So, if you’re a homeowner in California and wondering about your rights and responsibilities when it comes to a fence between you and your neighbor, read on to find out.

Equally Responsible for a Party Fence

In California, the default rule is that neighbors are equally responsible for the costs associated with building and maintaining a “party fence,” which is a fence that sits on the property line and serves as a boundary between two adjoining properties. This means that both neighbors are expected to share the costs of constructing, repairing, or replacing the fence, unless they mutually agree otherwise.

Good Neighbor Fence Act

California Civil Code Section 841, also known as the “Good Neighbor Fence Act,” outlines the guidelines for shared responsibility of a party fence. According to this law, both neighbors are presumed to benefit from the fence, and the costs of building, repairing, or replacing the fence should be shared equally, unless one neighbor chooses to opt out.

Exceptions to Shared Responsibility Rule

However, California law also provides exceptions to the shared responsibility rule. For example, if one neighbor wants to build a fence that is more expensive than what is reasonable for a simple boundary line fence, then that neighbor would be solely responsible for the additional costs. Similarly, if one neighbor wants to build a fence for a specific purpose, such as to enclose their swimming pool for safety reasons, then that neighbor would be responsible for the entire cost of the fence.

It’s important to note that the Good Neighbor Fence Act only applies to party fences, which are defined as fences that are located on the property line. If a fence is entirely located on one neighbor’s property, then that neighbor would be solely responsible for the costs associated with that fence, including construction, repair, and maintenance.

Written Agreements Between Neighbors

In some cases, neighbors may choose to enter into a written agreement that outlines their respective responsibilities for a fence. This can be done before the fence is built or after an issue arises. Such agreements can specify the design, materials, and costs associated with the fence, and can override the default rules under the Good Neighbor Fence Act.

Legal Action

In situations where neighbors cannot come to an agreement on the costs of a fence, or if there is a dispute regarding the condition or maintenance of the fence, either neighbor can take legal action to resolve the matter. This may involve seeking mediation or taking the matter to court.

In conclusion, in California, the default rule is that neighbors are equally responsible for the costs of a party fence unless they mutually agree otherwise. However, there are exceptions to this rule, and it’s important to understand your rights and responsibilities as a homeowner when it comes to building and maintaining a fence on your property line. If you have any questions or concerns, it’s best to consult with a qualified attorney or mediator to help you navigate the legal requirements and find a resolution that works for both you and your neighbor. Good communication and cooperation with your neighbor can also go a long way in resolving fence-related issues and maintaining a positive relationship with your neighbors.